Steven Gerrard in Talks with Rangers Over Managerial Return

Steven Gerrard, who guided Rangers to their historic 55th league title in 2021, is set for further discussions with the club’s American hierarchy following constructive talks on Thursday. The Liverpool legend has emerged as the frontrunner to return to Ibrox after Russell Martin’s dismissal, with negotiations exceeding expectations and sources indicating strong mutual enthusiasm for his comeback.

The Gerrard Era: A Golden Chapter in Rangers History

When Steven Gerrard arrived at Rangers in May 2018, the club was in desperate need of revival. Celtic’s dominance had been absolute, and the Ibrox faithful yearned for someone to restore pride and challenge for supremacy. What followed was one of the most remarkable transformations in Scottish football history.

The 2020-21 campaign stands as one of Scottish football’s greatest achievements: Rangers went unbeaten across all 38 league matches, accumulated 102 points, scored 92 goals, and conceded a record low of just 13. This wasn’t just winning—it was domination of the highest order.

The significance extended beyond statistics. Rangers claimed their 55th top-flight title, which included back-to-back Old Firm derby victories over Celtic, stopping their rivals’ bid for an unprecedented tenth consecutive championship. For Rangers supporters, Gerrard had delivered what seemed impossible just three years earlier.

Why Now? The Russell Martin Aftermath

Rangers’ decision to part ways with Russell Martin came after disappointing results that left the club trailing in the Scottish Premiership title race. The timing, while surprising to some observers, reflects the board’s ambition to salvage the season before it spirals beyond recovery.

Gerrard reportedly met with Rangers chiefs in London on Thursday, four days after Martin’s dismissal. The swift movement suggests the club had been considering contingency plans, with Gerrard’s name inevitably surfacing given his legendary status at Ibrox.

Current Rangers Situation:

• League Position: Trailing in the title race
• Next Match: Dundee United at Ibrox (week ahead)
• Season Objective: Reclaim Scottish Premiership dominance
• European Ambitions: Restore continental competitiveness

The club’s American ownership, led by owners seeking stability and success, view Gerrard as someone who understands Rangers’ DNA and has proven he can deliver at the highest level in Scottish football. His intimate knowledge of the club’s culture, fanbase expectations, and tactical requirements for Old Firm success make him an attractive candidate.

Gerrard’s Managerial Journey Since Rangers

After his triumphant departure from Rangers in November 2021, Gerrard took charge of Aston Villa in the Premier League. The move represented his ambition to manage at English football’s top level, but results proved mixed. Villa ultimately parted ways with Gerrard in October 2022 after a difficult spell that saw inconsistent performances and mounting pressure.

Most recently, Gerrard managed Al-Ettifaq in the Saudi Pro League, gaining experience in a different footballing culture and working with high-profile players. However, the allure of returning to a club where he achieved his greatest managerial success and remains beloved by supporters appears to have reignited his passion for the Ibrox hotseat.

The managerial maturity gained from these subsequent roles could prove invaluable. Gerrard experienced the harsh realities of Premier League management and the complexities of building projects in unfamiliar environments. These lessons, combined with his Rangers success, potentially make him a more complete manager than the one who left in 2021.

What Would Gerrard 2.0 Look Like?

A second Gerrard tenure would differ significantly from his first. The landscape has evolved, expectations have shifted, and the manager himself has accumulated valuable experience—both positive and challenging. Understanding what this return might entail requires examining several key factors.

Tactical Evolution

During his first Rangers stint, Gerrard favored a possession-based 4-3-3 system that emphasized high pressing, aggressive full-backs, and technical midfield control. His teams were characterized by defensive solidity and clinical counter-attacking football. The invincible season showcased a side that could both dominate possession and ruthlessly exploit defensive transitions.

Would he return with the same philosophy? Likely with refinements. Modern football has evolved tactically, and Gerrard’s subsequent experiences have exposed him to different approaches. Expect a system built on defensive organization but with enhanced flexibility to adapt during matches—something his first tenure occasionally lacked.

Squad Management Challenges

The current Rangers squad differs dramatically from the one Gerrard assembled and molded. New personalities, different strengths, and varying tactical profiles mean he cannot simply replicate his previous formula. Integration becomes crucial.

Key Considerations:

• Existing talent assessment: Identifying which current players fit his tactical vision
• Transfer market activity: January window opportunities to strengthen weak areas
• Youth development: Continuing Rangers’ tradition of promoting academy talent
• Team chemistry: Building the winning mentality that characterized his title-winning side

The Celtic Factor

Perhaps the most significant difference from 2018 is Celtic’s current strength. Brendan Rodgers has returned to Celtic Park and constructed a formidable team. The Old Firm rivalry remains Scottish football’s defining feature, and Gerrard’s record in these fixtures during his first tenure was exceptional.

Gerrard’s strong record against Celtic, particularly during the invincible season where Rangers secured back-to-back Old Firm victories, remains fresh in supporters’ memories. Replicating this dominance will be essential for any sustained title challenge.

The psychological aspect cannot be understated. Gerrard knows how to prepare Rangers for Glasgow derbies. He understands the intensity, the pressure, and the tactical adjustments required. This experience represents an invaluable asset that few other candidates could offer.

Fan Sentiment: A Hero’s Welcome or Cautious Optimism?

Rangers supporters remain divided on Gerrard’s potential return. Social media discourse reveals this split, with passionate arguments on both sides presenting compelling cases.

The Pro-Gerrard Camp:

• Proven winner at Rangers with historic achievements
• Understands club culture and supporter expectations
• Strong Old Firm record demonstrates big-game mentality
• Emotional connection could galvanize squad and fanbase
• Unfinished business after leaving for Aston Villa

The Skeptical Voice:

• Questions about his post-Rangers managerial record
• Concerns over potential squad compatibility issues
• Worry about managing heightened expectations
• Fear of tarnishing his legendary status with underwhelming return
• Doubts about whether he’s the progressive choice for modern football

Some observers have questioned Gerrard’s loyalty, given how he departed for Aston Villa during his previous tenure. This skepticism reflects concerns about commitment—will he view this as a stepping stone again, or a long-term project?

The truth likely lies somewhere between unbridled optimism and excessive caution. Gerrard possesses qualities that make him uniquely suited for Rangers, but success isn’t guaranteed. The context has changed, and football offers no certainties.

Other Candidates in the Frame

While Gerrard dominates headlines, Rangers are speaking to other candidates, with former Sheffield Wednesday manager Danny Rohl among those under consideration. This due diligence reflects professional recruitment practices—the board must explore all viable options before making such a crucial appointment.

Alternative Candidates Linked:

The board’s thorough approach suggests they’re weighing romantic appeal against pragmatic considerations. Gerrard’s emotional pull is undeniable, but appointing a manager requires analyzing tactical fit, personality compatibility with existing structures, and realistic assessment of championship capabilities.

The Timeline and Decision Process

Thursday’s discussions between Gerrard and the club’s US owners were described as constructive, suggesting positive momentum toward potential appointment. However, Rangers appear determined to conduct comprehensive interviews before making final decisions.

The club faces no immediate fixture pressure, with their next match against Dundee United not scheduled until the following Saturday. This breathing room allows for thoughtful deliberation rather than panic-driven appointments—a measured approach that serves long-term interests.

Decision Factors:

1. Tactical compatibility: Does the candidate’s philosophy suit the current squad?
2. Transfer market alignment: Can they identify and recruit necessary reinforcements?
3. Championship credibility: Do they possess the tactical acumen to overcome Celtic?
4. Cultural fit: Will they embrace Rangers’ traditions and supporter expectations?
5. Long-term vision: Are they committed to sustained success or viewing this as temporary?

What Success Looks Like in a Second Stint

If appointed, Gerrard’s objectives would be clear but challenging. The invincible season set an impossibly high bar, and replicating such perfection seems unrealistic. However, specific targets would define success.

Immediate Goals (Season 2025-26):

• Close gap to Celtic in league standings
• Restore competitive edge in Old Firm fixtures
• Achieve European qualification through league position
• Rebuild winning mentality and squad cohesion

Medium-Term Ambitions (2-3 Years):

• Win Scottish Premiership title
• Deep European competition runs
• Domestic cup success
• Develop sustainable playing style and recruitment model

The pressure will be immense. Gerrard’s previous achievements mean expectations won’t be modest—Rangers fans will demand championships, not just improvements. Whether he can handle this pressure having experienced managerial setbacks since leaving Ibrox remains the crucial question.

The Romantic Appeal vs. Pragmatic Reality

Football loves comeback stories. Legendary figures returning to clubs where they achieved glory carries emotional weight that transcends tactical analysis and statistical projections. Gerrard at Rangers represents this romantic narrative—a homecoming that could restore both his managerial reputation and the club’s competitive status.

Yet romance doesn’t guarantee results. Modern football demands more than sentiment and historical achievements. It requires adaptability, current tactical knowledge, and the ability to maximize available resources. Gerrard must prove he remains the right choice for Rangers’ current context, not just their past glory.

The coming days will reveal whether nostalgia and proven pedigree outweigh concerns about recent managerial struggles. For Rangers and Gerrard, this represents a high-stakes gamble with potential rewards and risks on both sides.

One certainty exists: should Steven Gerrard return to Ibrox, Scottish football’s spotlight will burn brighter than ever, with every result scrutinized and every tactical decision analyzed through the lens of his legendary first tenure. The stage is set for one of the most anticipated managerial appointments in recent Scottish football history.

Read More: Joan Laporta Confirms Barcelona Will Abandon Super League and Return to UEFA

FAQs