Saturday Night Live delivered a nostalgic homecoming on October 11, 2025, as comedy legend Amy Poehler returned to Studio 8H for her third hosting gig. The episode wasn’t just another SNL installment—it was a full-blown reunion that brought together some of the show’s most beloved alumni and featured breakout musical performances that had audiences on their feet.
The Host: Amy Poehler’s Third SNL Hosting Appearance
Amy Poehler took center stage for SNL Season 51 Episode 2, marking her third time as host and reinforcing her enduring connection to the iconic sketch comedy show. As a cast member from 2001 to 2008, Poehler helped define an era of SNL comedy before launching her massively successful career in television and film.
Her return carried special significance—the episode aired on the exact 50th anniversary of SNL’s very first broadcast. Poehler acknowledged this milestone during her monologue, keeping her opening remarks characteristically brief before diving into the evening’s comedy. She reflected on her cast member days and how the show shaped her career, setting a warm, nostalgic tone for the night.
Episode Highlights at a Glance
| Role | Name | Performance Details |
|---|---|---|
| Host | Amy Poehler | Third hosting appearance, former cast member |
| Musical Guest | Role Model | SNL debut, performed three hits |
| Special Guest | Tina Fey | Multiple sketches with Poehler |
| Special Guest | Seth Meyers | Weekend Update “Joke Off” |
| Special Guest | Aubrey Plaza | The Hunting Wives parody |
| Musical Surprise | Charli XCX | Joined Role Model for “Sally” |
The Reunion Everyone Wanted
What elevated this episode from good to unforgettable was the parade of surprise appearances. Tina Fey, Poehler’s longtime comedy partner and fellow SNL alumna, made multiple cameos throughout the night. Their chemistry remains as electric as ever, particularly in a sketch where they portrayed Attorney General Pam Bondi (Poehler) and Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem (Fey).
The duo also reunited with Seth Meyers for a hilarious Weekend Update “Joke Off” against current anchors Colin Jost and Michael Che. Watching three generations of Weekend Update talent face off was pure comedy gold. Fey and Yang later led a masterclass sketch on creating TV theme songs, showcasing the versatility that made these performers SNL legends.
Aubrey Plaza, Poehler’s Parks and Recreation co-star, also appeared in a sharp parody of The Hunting Wives, proving their on-screen chemistry extends well beyond Pawnee, Indiana.
Role Model Makes His SNL Debut
Musical guest Role Model brought fresh energy to the legendary stage with his SNL debut. The 28-year-old singer performed three tracks: “Sally,” “When The Wine Runs Out,” and “Some Protector.” His performance of “Sally” became an instant highlight when Charli XCX made a surprise appearance, joining him onstage to thunderous audience applause.
For fans tracking emerging music talent, Role Model’s SNL appearance represents a significant milestone. The show has long been a launching pad for artists on the verge of mainstream breakthrough, and his confident performance suggests he’s ready for that next level.
Political Satire Takes Center Stage
With the U.S. elections approaching, SNL Season 51 Episode 2 leaned heavily into political content. The “Pam Bondi Hearing Cold Open” set the tone, with Poehler and Fey tackling current political figures with their signature sharp wit. The show’s ability to balance timely political commentary with broader comedy sketches remains one of its enduring strengths.
According to NBC’s official programming, SNL continues to serve as America’s primary venue for political satire, a role that becomes even more crucial during election seasons.
Why This Episode Mattered
Beyond the laughs and musical performances, this episode demonstrated SNL’s unique ability to honor its legacy while staying relevant. Bringing back beloved cast members like Poehler, Fey, and Meyers creates a bridge between generations of fans—longtime viewers get their nostalgia fix while newer audiences discover why these performers became icons.
Poehler’s hosting proves she hasn’t lost a step. Her timing, delivery, and willingness to fully commit to absurd premises remind viewers why she became a comedy powerhouse. For those seeking comedy series recommendations, watching SNL alumni return to their roots offers a masterclass in sketch comedy.
How to Watch
SNL Season 51 continues its Saturday night tradition on NBC, with episodes also available for streaming on Peacock. The show maintains its familiar format: celebrity host, musical guest, and a mix of political satire and pop culture parodies that keep audiences guessing what’s next.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: How many times has Amy Poehler hosted Saturday Night Live?
Amy Poehler has hosted SNL three times, with her most recent appearance being Season 51 Episode 2 on October 11, 2025. She was a cast member on the show from 2001 to 2008 before launching her successful career in television and film. Her third hosting gig coincided perfectly with the 50th anniversary of SNL’s very first episode, which she referenced during her monologue. Her deep connection to the show makes her returns feel like true homecomings rather than just celebrity hosting gigs.
Q: Who were the surprise guests in SNL Season 51 Episode 2?
The episode featured several surprise appearances, most notably Tina Fey, who appeared in multiple sketches with Amy Poehler including a political cold open and a Weekend Update “Joke Off” alongside Seth Meyers. Aubrey Plaza, Poehler’s Parks and Recreation co-star, appeared in a parody of The Hunting Wives. Seth Meyers returned to the Weekend Update desk for the “Joke Off” segment. Additionally, Charli XCX made a surprise musical appearance during Role Model’s performance of “Sally,” sending the audience into cheers.
